* Translated by AI

Starnews

The strengths and weaknesses of Chairman Jin Ok-dong in his fourth year in office (2): What are the ills of a "rubber stamp" board of directors?

Published:

J H Song

*This content was translated by AI.View Original

Jin Ok-dong, Chairman of Shinhan Financial Group
Jin Ok-dong, Chairman of Shinhan Financial Group

Domestic investors watching the NVIDIA crisis following CEO Jensen Huang's departure would have been unable to contain their astonishment at the board of directors' formidable authority.

This is because Jensen Huang is a founder who holds a 3.5% stake in NVIDIA. Since co-founding NVIDIA in 1993, Jensen Huang has continuously served as CEO.

However, when an extramarital affair was revealed, the NVIDIA board immediately wielded a sharp blade against him, effectively expelling him from the company. Following the exposure of his affair with Alice Huang, who is suspected of being a Chinese spy, allegations of an office romance with Kimberly Powell, NVIDIA's Vice President of Healthcare, also surfaced. The board then convened an emergency meeting and effectively dismissed Jensen Huang. Although it took the form of his resignation, this was nothing more than granting the CEO an honorable exit in accordance with U.S. corporate conventions.

In South Korea as well, boards of directors hold the authority to dismiss the representative director. However, it is no exaggeration to say that the board's check-and-balance function is barely exercised, and there are virtually no cases of a CEO being dismissed for regulatory violations.

Shinhan Financial Holdings, where Chairman Jin Ok-dong serves as representative director, is no different. The board of directors, which oversees management, is in a state where it exists merely as a "rubber stamp," with its value as an oversight body nowhere to be found.

The Shinhan Financial Holdings board of directors, chaired by Kwak Soo-geun, an emeritus professor at Seoul National University's School of Business (outside director), is composed of 11 members: nine outside directors, Chairman Jin Ok-dong as an inside director, and Chung Sang-hyuk, President of Shinhan Bank, as a non-executive director. Let us examine whether the nine outside directors are fulfilling their function of checking management, including Chairman Jin Ok-dong, through the board, as stipulated by the Commercial Act.

According to Shinhan Financial Holdings' semi-annual report for this year, the board was convened six times in the first half. However, not a single director cast a dissenting vote on any agenda item at each meeting. The approval rate is 100%. It is no stretch to say that a board operating in this manner has no functioning check-and-balance mechanism whatsoever.

Of course, there is a counterargument that because outside directors engage in prior consultations, agenda items with dissenting opinions are not even put forward. However, judging by the outcomes of formal board meetings, it remains merely a rubber stamp. Last year, Shinhan Financial's outside directors received an average compensation of approximately 90 million won. Because they receive such high salaries while only playing a rubber-stamp role, outside director positions in the financial sector are commonly perceived as "sweet posts." This is why outside directors typically aim to please management and secure long tenures.

Is it because the board's check-and-balance function is virtually nonexistent that management has become lax? Various incidents and accidents continue to occur at affiliated companies within Shinhan Financial Group.

Since taking office in 2023, Chairman Jin Ok-dong has consistently declared his firm resolve to systematically strengthen internal controls to prevent financial accidents.

He likely emphasized the internal control function based on the recognition that avoiding financial accidents is paramount to achieving "First-Class Shinhan."

However, Chairman Jin's management philosophy has not been properly implemented in the field. At Shinhan Investment Corp, a large-scale loss of approximately 135.7 billion won occurred in October 2024 due to on-exchange futures trading unrelated to its core business purposes. It was revealed that those involved in the incident concealed the loss by registering false swap transactions. In response, the Financial Supervisory Service imposed a severe disciplinary warning restricting entry into new businesses following an investigation into the accident.

Accidents have also continued at Shinhan Bank, betraying customer trust. In May 2023, it was discovered that an employee at a Shinhan Bank branch had embezzled a customer's deposit. Around the same time, Shinhan Bank received disciplinary action from the Financial Supervisory Service and underwent a police raid on its headquarters due to improper sales of the Fidelis Trade Finance Fund. In November 2024, a breach of trust in business operations involving 1.34 billion won was revealed, leading to the employee being reported to authorities. In February 2025, an external fraud incident involving 1.998 billion won occurred. Subsequently, in March 2025, an employee embezzlement incident involving 170.72 million won came to light. This was a case where an employee handling import-export trade and corporate lending operations diverted large sums over more than three years by issuing false loans.

One can only wonder what warnings the Shinhan Financial Holdings board of directors has issued to management, including Chairman Jin Ok-dong who bears overall responsibility for affiliated companies, each time such incidents erupt. Chairman Jin Ok-dong was recommended as a candidate for the next chairman by the Chairman Candidate Recommendation Committee, composed of outside directors, at the end of last year, and successfully secured re-election through the shareholders' meeting in March this year.

Going forward, we hope that the outside directors who form the core of the Shinhan Financial Holdings board of directors will not merely watch management's reactions but faithfully fulfill their original check-and-balance function.

*This content was translated by AI.View Original

Recommended News

Editor’s Pick

Latest in Business & Lifestyle