* Translated by AI

Starnews

"A sexual minority known to Choi Dong-seok" — Park Ji-yoon rebuts, but court ruling cites "adulterous conduct" [Comprehensive]

Published:

Yun Seongyeol

*This content was translated by AI.View Original

  • Choi Dong-seok wins partial appeal in cohabitation lawsuit… Direct clash with Park Ji-yoon over the verdict
Choi Dong-seok (left) and Park Ji-yoon /Photo=Choi Dong-seok SNS, StarNews
Choi Dong-seok (left) and Park Ji-yoon /Photo=Choi Dong-seok SNS, StarNews

In an appellate ruling on a damages suit for cohabitation filed by broadcaster Choi Dong-seok against A, a male acquaintance of his ex-wife Park Ji-yoon, who is currently in divorce proceedings, the court partially ruled in favor of Choi. It was confirmed that the court determined that the fact that A is a sexual minority and cohabits with a same-sex partner alone does not negate the establishment of adulterous conduct with Park Ji-yoon. Although Park Ji-yoon expressed her grievance, stating she had "never considered A to be a man," the court recognized the adulterous conduct based on the specific actions of the two individuals and the circumstances at the time, rather than their sexual orientation. Subsequently, Choi Dong-seok and Park Ji-yoon have taken opposing stances regarding the appellate verdict, leading to another direct confrontation.

According to the appellate ruling reviewed by StarNews on the 19th, Family Division 1-1 (A) of the Jeju District Court determined that it cannot be concluded that adulterous conduct does not exist solely because A is a homosexual cohabiting with a same-sex partner.

The panel stated, "The fact that the defendant is a homosexual and is cohabiting with a same-sex partner alone does not allow for an evaluation that the defendant's actions do not constitute adulterous conduct in relation to a heterosexual couple."

This implies that A's sexual orientation or the fact of currently living with a same-sex partner does not serve as grounds to deny the establishment of adulterous conduct in the relationship with Park Ji-yoon. The panel determined whether adulterous conduct occurred based on the specific actions taken together with Park Ji-yoon and the circumstances at the time, rather than A's sexual orientation itself.

Accordingly, the panel recognized as adulterous conduct that failed to fulfill the marital duty of fidelity the acts of Park Ji-yoon and A staying at the same hotel during a trip to the United States in November 2022, remaining in the same room in pajamas, and watching movies together. According to Supreme Court precedents, adulterous conduct includes any behavior that fails to fulfill the marital duty of fidelity, even if it does not amount to adultery. In particular, the fact that the two did not inform Choi Dong-seok about such trips and meetings was also used as a basis for judgment.

A's side argued that they stayed in the same hotel room to help with the photography of Park Ji-yoon's group purchase products, but the panel did not accept this claim. The panel pointed out, "If the defendant (A) and Park Ji-yoon were on such good terms that they could travel without any issues, as the defendant claims, there would be no reason to hide this from the plaintiff (Choi Dong-seok)." It further judged that "Park Ji-yoon herself must have been aware that she could not tolerate the relationship with the defendant from the perspective of her heterosexual spouse, the plaintiff."

On the other hand, the trip to Vietnam by Park Ji-yoon and A in April 2024 was not recognized as adulterous conduct. This was because their marital relationship had already broken down at that time.

Broadcaster Park Ji-yoon /Photo=Kim Hwi-seon hwijpg@
Broadcaster Park Ji-yoon /Photo=Kim Hwi-seon hwijpg@

In this regard, Park Ji-yoon directly stated her position on the appellate ruling via social media on the same day. She rebutted, saying, "I believe this stems from a perspective that does not acknowledge homosexuality itself and assumes that sexual minorities can suddenly turn around and have affairs with the opposite sex at any time," adding, "I think this could be somewhat insulting to people with different sexual preferences."

Park Ji-yoon emphasized regarding A that she had "not considered him a man." She continued, "A also has a de facto spouse, and from when we first met at the age of 19, he has never once considered me a woman."

Park Ji-yoon, who treated A as she would a woman, explained, "Most of the trip itinerary consisted of conversations where I praised male actors and discussed topics usually shared by ordinary girlfriends, such as clothing, and sometimes comforting me when I was discouraged by my decision to divorce."

She also clarified that the trip to the United States was not taken alone with A. Park Ji-yoon stated, "On the trip to the United States in 2022, I departed with one female friend and traveled with two other female friends who were already in the U.S.; it was not a trip to meet a same-sex couple." However, she added, "We had such close family-like ties with a same-sex couple living at our layover destination that it would have been strange not to meet them, so we only shared part of the itinerary with them."

Park Ji-yoon also claimed that Choi Dong-seok was well aware of A and his de facto spouse, as well as his sexual orientation.

Park Ji-yoon conveyed, "Choi Dong-seok and he were close enough to exchange KakaoTalk messages just the two of them. Those living in the U.S., me, and Choi Dong-seok would eat together and visit each other's homes from time to time. Since we also traveled with our children, I considered them very intimate friends." She further confessed, "I was utterly bewildered from the moment I was first sued for cohabitation."

Park Ji-yoon also claimed that Choi Dong-seok suffered from "cervical dystonia" (a mistranslation of 'delusional jealousy' or 'Othello syndrome', but translated literally as 'disease of the wife' based on context of '의처증'). Park Ji-yoon stated, "Choi Dong-seok tried to portray me as an unfaithful woman. I wanted to deny the fact of his delusional jealousy, but I could no longer endure it. So in October 2023, I left the house with my children, which had already been discussed with our eldest child."

She also claimed that Choi Dong-seok had a relationship with another woman during the divorce proceedings. Park Ji-yoon said, "A few months later, while we were still living in the family home, Choi Dong-seok had a relationship with another woman despite being in divorce proceedings, and I witnessed them going back and forth between their homes with my own eyes."

She continued, "Of course, they may have started dating after their separation. Therefore, since I have no way of knowing when they started seeing each other, I filed a lawsuit against the cohabiting woman to have the court determine this. The court stated that it could not determine whether there was adulterous conduct before I left the house or after, and did not recognize liability for Choi Dong-seok's cohabiting woman."

Choi Dong-seok /Photo=Choi Dong-seok SNS
Choi Dong-seok /Photo=Choi Dong-seok SNS

Choi Dong-seok also responded directly to Park Ji-yoon's statement.

Choi Dong-seok countered, "Park Ji-yoon's statement completely ignores the facts that the court examined and recognized over a period of no less than three years, and is an extremely subjective, distorted, and one-sided claim written entirely from her own perspective. Moreover, the claims related to this cohabitation lawsuit amount to repeating arguments that the court did not accept and misleading public opinion."

He continued, "In this statement as well, Park Ji-yoon explains that she merely traveled with an acquaintance of a different sexual orientation and watched movies, but facts in a completely different context were recognized in the ruling, and the court made its judgment based on such facts." He added, "A person's sexual orientation is not something to be criticized in this case. The essence of the case lies in actions that betrayed the trust and responsibility that should be upheld in a marital relationship," stating, "It was Park Ji-yoon, not me, who emphasized this."

Choi Dong-seok also rebutted the claim that Park Ji-yoon was engaging in media manipulation against him.

Choi Dong-seok stated, "In October 2024, there was an incident where extremely private recordings and messages between the couple were widely disclosed through the media." He claimed, "At that time, an acquaintance of Park Ji-yoon reported to a media outlet about the divorce process. During the investigation process, I even asked them not to broadcast extremely private matters involving the couple or shameful behaviors of the opposing family. It was because I was worried that the children would be hurt."

He also emphasized that Park Ji-yoon's claims regarding himself and a female acquaintance were matters where legal judgment had already been concluded.

Choi Dong-seok pointed out, "Park Ji-yoon previously filed a cohabitation lawsuit directly against my female acquaintance, the court dismissed her claim, and since Park Ji-yoon did not appeal, the ruling became final." He noted, "Even though the court has already made a clear judgment, Park Ji-yoon is claiming false facts while talking about the relationship."

Meanwhile, Family Division 1-1 of the Jeju District Court ruled on the 16th in the appellate hearing of the damages claim lawsuit filed by Choi Dong-seok against A, partially ruling in favor of the plaintiff and ordering A to pay 30 million won in consolation money. If they disagree with the appellate ruling, the parties may appeal to the Supreme Court.

Previously, in January, the first-instance court dismissed all cohabitation-related lawsuits filed by both sides, but Choi Dong-seok appealed against this decision. Park Ji-yoon did not appeal, so her loss in the lawsuit she filed became final.

Choi Dong-seok and Park Ji-yoon met as fellow recruits of the 30th public recruitment for KBS announcers in 2004 and married in 2009. They have one son and one daughter. The couple applied for divorce mediation in October 2023, ending their 14-year marriage. The main divorce lawsuit is currently being conducted separately.

*This content was translated by AI.View Original

Recommended News

Editor’s Pick

Latest in Entertainment