Prosecution Service "Factual Error" Nana Home Invasion Man Sentenced to 7 Years in Prison, Both Parties Appeal [Comprehensive]

*This content was translated by AI.

Following the 7th-year prison sentence for man A, who broke into the home of Nana, a former member of the girl group After School, both the Prosecution Service and A have filed appeals, sending the case into a second round of trial.

On the 10th, A personally submitted an appeal against his 7-year sentence for robbery and injury. Subsequently, the Prosecution Service also filed an appeal on the 15th, stating, "Although the trial court found all the charges against the defendant guilty, it classified the offense against victim Nana as robbery causing injury rather than robbery causing death." The Prosecution Service added that the appeal was filed on grounds including "factual error, misinterpretation of law, and inappropriate sentencing."

The First Criminal Division (Da) of the Uijeongbu District Court, Namyangju Branch, held a sentencing hearing for A on the 9th regarding the charge of robbery and injury, sentencing him to 7 years in prison. In the earlier closing arguments, the Prosecution Service requested a 10-year prison term for A, stating, "The severity of the crime is serious, the defendant has shown no remorse, and no settlement has been reached with the victims."

On that day, the trial court stated, "First, we find the defendant guilty of robbery and injury against Nana's mother. However, the offense against Nana appears to be more appropriately classified as robbery causing death rather than robbery causing injury." The court continued, "We determined that the defendant was carrying a knife at the time. Considering the specific and consistent testimonies of the victims, as well as the defendant's own admission in a secretly posted online message seeking legal advice before handing himself over to the police shortly after the crime, which acknowledged he possessed the knife for dangerous purposes, we reached this conclusion based on these circumstances."

The court further noted, "Even if it is accepted that the defendant engaged in a physical struggle to suppress the victim's resistance and set the knife aside, and that Nana stabbed the defendant's neck with the knife during that moment, such an injury does not necessarily constitute a criminal injury." The court pointed out, "The victim acted in self-defense against the defendant."

The trial court added, "The defendant entered the home at night, when absolute peace should be maintained, while armed with a weapon, committing robbery and injury, and even robbery causing death. Considering the gravity and seriousness of the crime, a corresponding punishment is unavoidable." The court continued, "The victims suffered physical and mental pain and expressed their desire for punishment against the defendant, who has a history of multiple criminal offenses. However, we took into account that the crime was attempted, injuries occurred during the process, there is no indication the defendant intended to use the knife as a means of killing, and considered the nature and circumstances of the injuries sustained by the victims."

A was arrested and prosecuted for breaking into Nana's residence in Achon-dong, Guri-si, Gyeonggi-do, on the morning of November 15, 2025, and attempting to steal money by threatening Nana and her mother with a weapon.

During the incident, Nana and her mother subdued A through a physical struggle and handed him over to the police. Subsequently, A filed a counter-complaint against Nana for attempted murder and other charges, claiming he was injured while being subdued by Nana and her mother. However, the police determined Nana's actions were justified self-defense and decided not to prosecute. Nana filed a counter-complaint against A for false accusation.

During his interrogation, A stated, "There was no knife during the home invasion. I was surprised when I faced Nana's mother. She was also startled and told me to leave, so I only came to steal things to calm her down, but she pushed me." He continued, "Nana's mother threatened me with a knife at my neck and stabbed me. I tried to calm her down by hugging her and did not strangle her." He added, "After being stabbed with the knife, I bled heavily. I was also hit multiple times by Nana's mother. I was holding the knife blade with both hands, and if I let go, I would have died. I then held it with my right hand. I even heard the sound of skin tearing. Eventually, the standoff ended. I committed no assault. If hugging counts as assault, I admit it."

A explained, "I answered all their questions about why I did this, my name, and my age. My mother collapsed from a brain hemorrhage and is in the hospital. Since I had borrowed 10 million won in fines from her from a previous trial, I ended up stealing things." He further stated, "Nana said she would call the police if I brought a knife. We talked for about 30 minutes, and then they immediately reported it to the police."

A replied, "I admit my mistake, but there is absolutely no truth to claims that I brought a knife, strangled anyone, or committed assault. I have reflected deeply. I am truly sorry." He also said, "At the time of the intrusion, I did not know the victim was Nana; I only learned this during the police investigation."

Nana and her mother appeared as witnesses at the third trial hearing for A's robbery and injury charge on April 21. At that time, upon seeing A in court, Nana immediately said, "Is this fun?" expressing her anger. She then told A, "You commit robberies and roam around freely. Is this fun? Look me in the eye. Is this fun?" A did not avert his gaze but stared back at Nana.

In the subsequent interrogation, Nana spoke about the situation at the time of the incident: "After experiencing this event, I thought I was fine. But unconsciously, it has remained as a trauma in my life. I came here praying for the case to be resolved quickly," expressing her trauma.

After the trial, Nana shared on her fan communication platform, "Seeing him face-to-face made me so speechless and angry that I lost control of my emotions. However, I was able to say everything I wanted to say clearly and openly." She added, "I also said what I wanted to say to that man, and I have no regrets about my actions or words. Everyone must have been very worried, but I am fine. I believe this will now be concluded."

Nana also posted on her SNS account, "I hope you pay the price for all the heinous crimes you have committed so far," and shared the phrase "jagapjadeok" (self-inflicted consequences), which means receiving the consequences of one's own actions.

Later, on the 9th, Nana posted on her SNS, "Who is the victim?" She continued, "Multiple trials by the criminal. Six public trials, one closing trial today, totaling seven trials. Consistent false testimony and retraction. The criminal shows no remorse."

She then emphasized, "During this process, the Prosecution Service requested a 10-year sentence. The trial court sentenced him to 3 years and 7 years in prison. Special robbery causing injury carries a minimum of 7 years imprisonment. There is no remorse. There is no forgiveness."

Subsequently, on the 11th, Nana posted on her SNS a screenshot of an article headline stating that the robbery suspect, who was charged with breaking into her home and committing robbery and injury, had appealed the first-instance sentence of 7 years in prison.

Regarding this, Nana added a brief comment, "Wasting time. Only laughter," revealing her feelings. She also included the word "Fighting" on a black image.

<© STARNEWS. All rights reserved. No reproduction or redistribution allowed.>

*This content was translated by AI.