*This content was translated by AI.View Original
The court ordered Chang Hyeong-jin, an advisor to Yeongpoong, to submit the full text of the management cooperation agreement signed with MBK Partners. However, controversy has arisen as it is known that Yeongpoong, rather than Advisor Chang, submitted a version of the agreement with certain portions redacted. Questions have been raised over whether the document submission order was properly fulfilled, particularly given that some clauses were obscured even after the court reviewed the full text of the agreement and rejected claims for non-disclosure on grounds of trade secrets.
According to recent reports from legal circles, the Supreme Court dismissed a petition for further appeal filed by Advisor Chang’s side in August regarding the document submission order, without conducting an oral hearing. Consequently, the lower court’s decision was upheld, which identified Advisor Chang as the holder of the documents and ordered the submission of the “agreement related to the basic contract on management cooperation” signed with MBK, along with any subsequent agreements.
The agreement in question was signed in September 2024 while Yeongpoong and MBK were pursuing control of Korea Zinc’s management rights. It is understood that the agreement stipulated the cooperative relationship between the two parties regarding share acquisition, exercise of voting rights, securing management control, and future participation in management.
Advisor Chang’s litigation representative stated at a hearing for the shareholder derivative suit held on August 27 that they would submit the relevant agreement in accordance with the Supreme Court’s decision. It was reported that there was no mention at the time of redacting parts of the agreement or submitting it under a third party’s name.
However, the entity that actually submitted the agreement on September 30 was Yeongpoong, not Advisor Chang. It is understood that significant portions of the submitted basic agreement and other documents were redacted for reasons including trade secrets.
Notably, it is known that the court had previously reviewed the entire agreement before ordering its submission. Advisor Chang’s side argued that some content needed to be obscured because the contract contained sensitive information such as trade secrets, but the court did not accept this argument.
Nevertheless, with the submission of an agreement containing redacted clauses, there are concerns that it is difficult to fully verify specific rights and obligations under the contract, economic burdens, and conditions related to management control.
The fact that the submitting entity was Yeongpoong rather than Advisor Chang is also a point of contention. Since Yeongpoong is neither the defendant in the shareholder derivative suit nor the party designated by the court for the document submission order, controversy is expected over whether Yeongpoong’s submission can be considered as Advisor Chang complying with the court’s order.
Previously, it is known that Advisor Chang’s side disputed the document submission order, arguing that key contents of the agreement had already been disclosed through public disclosures and media reports, and that disclosing the full text of the agreement could affect Yeongpoong’s management control and shareholder interests.
In this shareholder derivative suit, a major issue is the process by which Yeongpoong’s management signed the management cooperation agreement and whether it infringed upon the company’s interests. Accordingly, attention is focused on whether the redacted clauses include provisions regarding Yeongpoong’s economic burdens or restrictions on rights related to management control.
Inside and outside legal circles, there are indications that explanations are needed for why certain contents were redacted despite the court ordering the submission of the full text, and why it was submitted under Yeongpoong’s name rather than Advisor Chang’s. However, the specific content and legal effect of the redacted clauses have not yet been confirmed.
<© STARNEWS. All rights reserved. No reproduction or redistribution allowed.>
*This content was translated by AI.View Original







!['2 draws and 7 losses in the first 9 matches → Champions Final title' reversal... Manager Park Nam-yeol: "Thanks to the players who worked hard" [Suwon on-site]](https://image.starnewskorea.com/cdn-cgi/image/f=auto,w=640,h=427,fit=cover,g=face/21/2026/11/2026111817225616431_1.jpg)




